Skip to content

Corruption Ledger

The Public Ledger of Corruption

  • Home
  • About CL
  • Rumble
  • Video
  • corruption
    • corporate corruption
    • government corruption
    • leaks
    • Misinformation
    • Surveillance
  • cryptocurrency
  • Sanctions Feeds
    • All Sanctions Feeds
    • Canadian Sanctions
    • US Sanctions
  • Toggle search form

KPMG India in a Million Dollar Settlement with a US Regulator and Not Even a Ripple in India

Posted on December 23, 2022 By 5amResearch No Comments on KPMG India in a Million Dollar Settlement with a US Regulator and Not Even a Ripple in India

KPMG India settled a proceeding before the US Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) on 6 December 2022; but there is barely any coverage by the Indian media. PCAOB, which audits public companies, censured KPMG Assurance and Consulting Services LLP (KPMG India) and the engagement partner (EP) Sagar P Lakhani for quality control failures, supervisory failures and documentation failures while working with a public company in 2017. It led to a monetary penalty of US$1mn (million) on KPMG India and US$75,000 on Mr Lakhani, who is also suspended from associating with a registered public accounting firm for one year and requires the audit firm to “undertake and certify the completion of certain improvements to its system of quality control” systems.

This is the second such sanction in connection with an Indian listed entity. The last time was when the infamous Satyam Computers imploded. In May 2011, PCOAB settled an investigation imposing a penalty of US$1.5mn in addition to US$6mn imposed by the Securities Exchange Commission (SEC) of the US on five firms of PricewaterhouseCoopers International (PWC) in India. The five PWC entities who participated in the settlement were: Price Waterhouse and Price Waterhouse & Co in Bengaluru, Lovelock & Lewes, Price Waterhouse and Price Waterhouse & Co, Kolkata.

At that time, PCAOB’s order correctly said, “The reliability of global capital markets depends on auditors fulfilling their obligation to investors to perform robust audits, resulting in well-founded audit reports.” That is why it is surprising that the latest order against KPMG has made no ripples, and there isn’t a peep out of India’s market regulator or audit regulators – the rather tame self-regulatory body Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) or the more aggressive national financial reporting authority (NFRA).

India’s investor population had doubled in the past three years and, while our regulators have indeed been more active in recent years in response to huge corporate blowouts, one expects some public indication of a follow-up on the KPMG India matter. There are several good reasons for this. First, since it is a settlement, the order does not identify the listed company in which these lapses occurred in 2017. All it says is that the ‘issuer’ is into wholesale and retail banking and treasury services, headquartered in Mumbai.

Among other things, Mr Lakhani and his colleagues were found signing off on blank work papers that were later “replaced with completed work papers, in many cases after the issuance of the audit report, but the sign off dates were not updated.” Shockingly, completed versions of the work papers were replaced in 2017 after KPMG India had released its audit report and before the documentation completion date.

The detailed order documents how eAudIT, a proprietary software of KPMG, was misused—the organisation was aware of it but did not stop the misuse. Did the sign-off on blank documents only happen with ‘Issuer A’, the bank referred to in the PCAOB order? Was Mr Lakhani the only engagement partner who did this, or was he just unfortunate to be caught? ICAI, NFRA and the Securities & Exchange Board of India (SEBI) ought to investigate how extensive was the practice and what impact it had on the final audit reports. I emailed KPMG India’s communications department for comments on the PCAOB order. This article will be updated if they respond. The PCAOB order does say that KPMG India has ‘disciplined certain of its personnel’ and has ‘established and implemented’ changes to its quality control policies and procedures.

Who Is Issuer A?
PCAOB’s order does not even go into the impact of these lapses, if any, on the accounts of the unnamed bank, whose identity should matter to Indian investors and regulators. Since KPMG India and Mr Lakhani are, together, coughing up US$1,075,000, one assumes that the lapses are serious enough to warrant further investigation and Indian investors have the right to demand more information.

The spotlight in this case would be on a Mumbai-based private bank with US listing. I reached out to some senior people with KPMG links, but they have chosen to remain silent. This is no surprise either; the auditing profession has got away with very relaxed oversight over the decades by ICAI. When NFRA chose to be a lot tougher, the profession, barring exceptions, closed ranks to try and defang the new regulator through the ministry of corporate affairs (MCA).

MoneyLife

. . . . . . . . . . . . .

  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Telegram (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
corruption Tags:KPMG, PWC

Post navigation

Previous Post: TikTok employees spied on journalists investigating social network
Next Post: Ex-Tokyo Olympics official Takahashi granted ¥80 million bail in bribery case

Related Posts

  • Four Men Convicted of Engaging in a Child Exploitation Enterprise corruption
  • Aerojet Rocketdyne Whistleblower To Receive $2.61 Million in False Claims Act Settlement corruption
  • Ukrainian oligarch accused of money laundering, embezzlement arrested at French ski resort corruption
  • Ukrainian Trust in Authorities Decreases corruption
  • Romanian court upholds arrest of influencer Andrew Tate corruption
  • The most hated cryptocurrency: Why are people flocking to Monero? corruption

Comment Cancel reply

  • Glenn Greenwald: Revealed – Mass Media Complicity in “Russian Disinformation” Fraud, w/ Matt Taibbi | SYSTEM UPDATE #30January 30, 2023
  • Reports of drone attacks in Iran and SyriaJanuary 29, 2023
  • AP: Ukraine Corruption Scandal; U.S. likely to OK sending Abrams tanksJanuary 29, 2023
  • Classified documents probe pushes Biden think tank into spotlightJanuary 29, 2023
  • British PM Sunak fires party chairman over tax bill allegationsJanuary 29, 2023
  • North Korea calls U.S. pledge of tanks to Ukraine ‘unethical crime’January 28, 2023
  • Usain Bolt fires business manager over Jamaica fraud caseJanuary 27, 2023
  • Canada’s Supreme Court gives mixed rulings on gun crime penaltiesJanuary 27, 2023
  • China, U.S. spar at WTO meeting over disputesJanuary 27, 2023
  • David J. Miller and Minnesota Independent Cooperative, Inc., Convicted in Multi-Million-Dollar Prescription Drug Diversion SchemeJanuary 27, 2023
  • Philippines to appeal ICC resumption of drug war probe: Thousands deadJanuary 27, 2023
  • Turkey says Sweden complicit in hate crime, NATO talks pointlessJanuary 26, 2023
  • Five Members and Associates of White Supremacist Gang Sentenced to Life in Prison for Racketeering, Kidnapping, and MurderJanuary 26, 2023
  • Justice Department Finds Louisiana Department of Public Safety and Corrections Violates the Constitution By Incarcerating People Beyond Their Release DatesJanuary 25, 2023
  • Four Men Convicted of Engaging in a Child Exploitation EnterpriseJanuary 25, 2023
  • AP: Twitter faces lawsuits over unpaid rent for HQ offices in U.S., UKJanuary 24, 2023
  • U.S. Justice Department sues Google over digital advertising dominanceJanuary 24, 2023
  • Defence minister won’t say whether Canada is willing to send battle tanks to UkraineJanuary 23, 2023
  • Norway detains former top Wagner Group member seeking asylum, Andrey MedvedevJanuary 23, 2023
  • Finance companies and their directors fined for misconductJanuary 23, 2023
  • anti-government resistance
  • corruption
  • crime
  • dimwit crimes
  • economy
  • human rights
  • investigations
  • leaks
  • misinformation & censorship
  • political unrest
  • regulatory
  • sanctions
  • surveillance & privacy
  • war
  • who cares?

Corruption Ledger Follow

The Public ▇▇▇ Ledger of ▇▇▇ Corruption. https://t.co/wkobrEotQR

5amResearch
Corruption Ledger @5amresearch ·
3h

Cryptome content is reliable. Why is their @Twitter account permanently banned, however? https://twitter.com/Cryptome_org @Cryptome_org

Alex @Alex06944477

@MsQuitoSwarm @YouTube This seems to be legit, i read about the CIA-Operation "Aerodynamic" on the heise online german news platform
https://cryptome.org/2016/01/cia-ua-aerodynamic.pdf

Reply on Twitter 1622040205074075652 Retweet on Twitter 1622040205074075652 Like on Twitter 1622040205074075652
Retweet on Twitter Corruption Ledger Retweeted
System Update @systemupdate_ ·
2 Feb

.@RepMTG on protecting whistleblowers like Snowden & Assange:

“When a govt. is trying to stop the truth from being told… that’s something to pay attention to… We have to do everything we can to protect those whistleblowers who are risking their lives to tell the truth.”

Reply on Twitter 1621266228009394179 Retweet on Twitter 1621266228009394179 118 Like on Twitter 1621266228009394179 485
Retweet on Twitter Corruption Ledger Retweeted
Corruption Ledger @5amresearch ·
31 Jan

The most uplifting news in ages: #France brings new meaning to "Power to the People" - unionized energy workers give free power to low income people, cut off electricity for the powerful. #vivelafrance https://www.france24.com/en/europe/20230127-robin-hood-energy-strikers-give-free-power-to-french-schools-hospitals-low-income-homes

Reply on Twitter 1620285867926622208 Retweet on Twitter 1620285867926622208 3 Like on Twitter 1620285867926622208
Corruption Ledger @5amresearch ·
31 Jan

The most uplifting news in ages: #France brings new meaning to "Power to the People" - unionized energy workers give free power to low income people, cut off electricity for the powerful. #vivelafrance https://www.france24.com/en/europe/20230127-robin-hood-energy-strikers-give-free-power-to-french-schools-hospitals-low-income-homes

Reply on Twitter 1620285867926622208 Retweet on Twitter 1620285867926622208 3 Like on Twitter 1620285867926622208
Load More
  • UK government webinar on Russia trade sanctions & commercial services
    EU Sanctions - UK 1 day ago
  • US designates international sanctions evasion network
    EU Sanctions - UK 1 day ago
  • Security Council ISIL (Da'esh) and Al-Qaida Sanctions Committee Amends 29 Entries to Its Sancti...
    UN.org 2 days ago
  • Canada Amends Myanmar Sanctions: 6 Individuals Targeted and New Prohibition on Aviation Fuel
    Baker Mckenzie - Canada 2 days ago
  • Oil Price Cap Update: Refined Products
    OFSI 2 days ago
  • United States: Government Designates Russian Proxy Wagner Group as a Significant Transnational Crimi...
    Sanctions – Global Compliance News 2 days ago
  • Ukraine introduces a new set of sanctions against Russian and Belarusian companies
    Baker McKenzie UK 2 days ago
  • United States: OFAC issues amended Russia-related General Licenses and related FAQs
    Sanctions – Global Compliance News 2 days ago
  • Oil broker arrested over supply of 18,000 tonnes of diesel to North Korea
    EU Sanctions - UK 3 days ago
  • Switzerland implements the 9th package of EU sanctions against Russia
    Baker Mckenzie US 3 days ago
  • Statement by Minister Ng on U.S. request for dispute settlement panel on tariff rate quotas for Cana...
    Canada.ca 4 days ago
  • UK, US & Canada impose sanctions to mark anniversary of Myanmar coup
    EU Sanctions - UK 4 days ago
  • US Government Designates Russian Proxy Wagner Group as a Significant Transnational Criminal Organiza...
    Baker McKenzie UK 5 days ago
  • UK Court judgment on the impact of sanctions on litigation / judgments involving designated persons;...
    EU Sanctions - UK 5 days ago
  • Japan introduces further sanctions against Russia
    Baker Mckenzie US 5 days ago
  • AP: Ukraine Corruption Scandal; U.S. likely to OK sending Abrams tanks
    JapanToday 6 days ago
  • Classified documents probe pushes Biden think tank into spotlight
    JapanToday 6 days ago
  • British PM Sunak fires party chairman over tax bill allegations
    JapanToday 6 days ago
  • North Korea calls U.S. pledge of tanks to Ukraine 'unethical crime'
    JapanToday 7 days ago
  • OFAC Issues Amended Russia-Related General Licenses and Related FAQs
    Baker McKenzie UK 7 days ago
1
2
3
…
Next

–

  • Register
  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org
  • Ionut-Razvan Sandu Sentenced for Role in International Fraud Scheme corruption
  • U.S. Justice Department sues Google over digital advertising dominance government corruption
  • Coming soon. Worth the wait. investigations
  • United States warrant for seizure of airplane of sanctioned Russian oligarch Andrei Skoch corruption
  • Former Twitter Employee 42 Prison Sentence for Acting as Foreign Agent, Selling User Data crime
  • Not being covered in media: Official UK data on adverse reactions to vaccination and “excess deaths” corporate corruption

Copyright © 2022 Corruption Ledger. This web site contains no ads.