Skip to content

Corruption Ledger

The Public Ledger of Corruption

  • About
  • Corruption
    • banks
    • corporate
    • environment
    • government
    • health
    • Leaks
    • misinformation
    • privacy and surveillance
    • Protest and Unrest
  • Sanctions
    • Sanctions News
    • Global Sanctions Feed
    • European Sanctions Feed
    • Canadian Sanctions Feed
    • US Sanctions Feed
  • Regions
    • Asias
    • Europe
    • Middle East
    • Oceania
    • US & Canada
    • World
  • Enforcement
  • Economy
  • International Conflict
  • Tech
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Free Speech
  • Toggle search form
  • Wells Fargo fined for sanctions breach _enforcement
  • Google Co-Founder, Other Billionaires Are Issued Subpoenas in Lawsuit Over JPMorgan’s Ties to Jeffrey Epstein; Sergey Brin, Thomas Pritzker, Mortimer Zuckerman and Michael Ovitz are asked for information in U.S. Virgin Islands’ civil suit against bank All Regions
  • Chinese businessman Guo Wengui seeks bail in $1 billion fraud case All Regions
  • IMF approves $15.6 billion Ukraine loan, part of $115 billion in global support All Regions
  • Russian preventive strike ‘petition’ possible after Ukrainian nuke plea -ITAR-TASS All Regions
  • Dominion’s Fox News defamation case headed to trial All Regions
  • Pussy Riot Member Accused of ‘Insulting Religious Sensibilities’, adds her to wanted list All Regions
  • Finland Clears Last Obstacle to NATO Entry All Regions

Honeywell allegedly sells faulty bulletproof vests to law enforcement, settles case for $3.35 million

Posted on October 29, 2022November 30, 2022 By CorruptionLedger No Comments on Honeywell allegedly sells faulty bulletproof vests to law enforcement, settles case for $3.35 million

U.S. v. Honeywell International Inc., case number 1:08-cv-00961, in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia.

Honeywell will pay $3.35 million to settle a long-running False Claims Act suit over allegedly faulty body armor sold to law enforcement, following a circuit court ruling that had significantly limited its potential liability, the U.S. Department of Justice announced Wednesday.

The deal resolves allegations that between 2000 and 2005, Honeywell International Inc. had sold “Z Shield” Zylon fiber material to a bulletproof vest manufacturer that Honeywell knew was not suitable for ballistic use due to its degrading quickly in hot and humid conditions, the DOJ said.

Honeywell is the last of 18 manufacturers and suppliers to settle after being accused of a role in selling defective Zylon fiber vests to federal agencies and to state, local and tribal law enforcement, finally ending a related investigation, according to the DOJ.

That long-running industrywide investigation and the related settlements, which had totaled more than $133 million before Honeywell reached its agreement, had demonstrated “the department’s resolve to hold accountable those businesses and individuals who supplied Zylon-containing bulletproof vests,” Brian Boynton, head of the DOJ’s Civil Division, said in a statement on Wednesday.

“The safety of law enforcement officers is of paramount importance, and we are committed to ensuring that taxpayer dollars go only to the high-quality ballistic protection our first responders deserve,” Boynton said.

Honeywell, in a statement to Law360 on Wednesday, said it was “pleased to announce” the resolution of the case, and viewed the “modest settlement amount as a reasonable way to settle this long-standing litigation.”

The company continued to deny any liability or that it made any false claims related to Z Shield, which it stopped selling in 2005, it said.

“Honeywell has long maintained that the Z Shield ballistic material at issue in the lawsuit was safe and effective,” the company said. “Ballistic vests containing Z Shield were sold to various … law enforcement agencies and have resulted in at least five confirmed saves of police officers shot in the line of duty. In both the investigation and the litigation, the U.S. Government did not identify a single instance where a vest containing Z Shield failed to perform as intended in the field.”

The DOJ had sued Honeywell in 2008 over the sale of Z Shield material to Armor Holdings, a manufacturer of bulletproof vests. As Honeywell’s case dragged on for more than a decade, the other 17 companies accused of selling defective vests or fiber, including Armor Holdings, all reached related settlements.

Following those settlements, Honeywell moved for a ruling in June 2019 that it should be allowed a pro tanto, or dollar-for-dollar, reduction in its potential damages due to the “common damages” addressed by the settlements. As its alleged liability, with the FCA’s trebled damages applied, was roughly $35 million, that would have effectively zeroed out any potential damages owed, leaving only potential civil penalties for each false claim.

U.S. District Judge Paul L. Friedman in the District of Columbia denied the company’s motion in November 2020, backing the government’s view that Honeywell should still be on the hook for a “proportionate share” of total damages, but in June 2021 he let the company appeal so the D.C. Circuit could weigh in.

Judge Friedman said that the issue involved an unresolved question of law that was the subject of an intra-circuit split, and that although he believed the proportionate share approach “would, on balance, produce a more equitable result,” there were also “not insubstantial” arguments in favor of the pro tanto approach, such as “concerns related to overcompensating the United States.”

The D.C. Circuit in August of this year backed the pro tanto approach to deciding damages when accounting for settlements already made by other defendants. U.S. Circuit Judge Neomi Rao wrote for the court that it “best fits with the FCA and the joint and several liability applied to FCA claims.”

There was no specific settlement offset rule or similar common law term included in the FCA for parties who cause the “same indivisible harm” to the government, Judge Rao said.

But using the proportionate share approach would clash with both U.S. Supreme Court precedent on joint and several liability in the FCA context and a long-held common law principle “that settlement with, or successful litigation against, one party reduces the damages owed by other parties who are jointly liable,” she said.

Source: Law360

Corruption Tags:Honeywell

Post navigation

Previous Post: California Acts to Stop Ygrene Energy Fund from Deceiving Consumers About PACE Financing, Placing Liens on Homes Without Consumer Consent
Next Post: Students Misled by Saint James Medical School’s Deceptive Marketing Claims

See also

  • Longtime Trump CFO Weisselberg gets 5 months in jail in tax fraud case _enforcement
  • Italy’s most-wanted Mafia boss nabbed after 30 years on run _enforcement
  • Zeit Online: Germany planning to ban Huawei, ZTE from parts of 5G networks Corruption
  • CEO of Ontrak Inc. Publicly Traded Health Care Company Charged for Insider Trading Scheme _enforcement
  • Eli Lilly whistleblower fired after reporting manufacturing problems at NJ plant Corruption
  • NIH, Wuhan were working on Monkeypox Corruption

You must log in to post a comment.

  • Wells Fargo fined for sanctions breach
  • Google Co-Founder, Other Billionaires Are Issued Subpoenas in Lawsuit Over JPMorgan’s Ties to Jeffrey Epstein; Sergey Brin, Thomas Pritzker, Mortimer Zuckerman and Michael Ovitz are asked for information in U.S. Virgin Islands’ civil suit against bank
  • Chinese businessman Guo Wengui seeks bail in $1 billion fraud case
  • IMF approves $15.6 billion Ukraine loan, part of $115 billion in global support
  • Dominion’s Fox News defamation case headed to trial
  • Pussy Riot Member Accused of ‘Insulting Religious Sensibilities’, adds her to wanted list
  • Russian preventive strike ‘petition’ possible after Ukrainian nuke plea -ITAR-TASS
  • Finland Clears Last Obstacle to NATO Entry
  • Macron announces water saving plan; says protests will not stop reforms
  • Kremlin comments on WSJ correspondent arrest
  • Minnesota derailment spills ethanol, prompts evacuations
  • Deutsche Bank Stock Tumbles On Contagion Fears
  • Wall St falls as bank contagion fears flare up
  • US due diligence firm Mintz Group says staff detained in China after office raid
  • Credit Suisse, UBS facing US Russia-sanctions probe, subpoenas also sent to employees major US banks
  • (US) Appeals court sides with Justice Department in Trump lawyer fight
  • Russia boosts defenses near Japan; accuses U.S. of expanding Asia-Pacific presence
  • US credit card debt at record high as Fed raises rates again
  • Russian tech giants appeal Nasdaq delisting
  • China Denounces Submarine Deal
  • China insists it is impartial on Russia-Ukraine, questions US ‘pouring weapons into the conflict’
  • German ambassador confirms that Putin would be arrested if he entered Germany
  • Danish Navy present near Nord Stream 2 – media
  • Railroad reluctant to say who OK’d chemical burn after Ohio derailment
  • Scientists insist on continuing search for toxics in East Palestine
  • Top aide of Canadian PM Trudeau will testify in parliament on Chinese election meddling
  • Zuckerberg, Meta sued for failing to address sex trafficking, child exploitation
  • Norfolk Southern: Independent group finds toxic chemicals that Ohio EPA didn’t – Ohio train derailment (East Palestine)
  • JP Morgan, Deutsche Bank to face lawsuit over Epstein ties
  • Putin announces readiness to switch to the Chinese Yuan currency in foreign trade
  • Putin and Xi sign two documents in Moscow
  • Russia says jet scrambled as US B-52 bombers fly over Baltic Sea
  • Paris police, protesters clash for third night over Macron’s pension reform
  • Global / ChipMixer software ‘taken down’ by multi-national law enforcement coalition
  • Russian officials scoff at ICC’s indictment of Putin
  • SVB parent company files for bankruptcy
  • Violent protests in France over Macron’s retirement age push
  • International court issues war crimes warrant for Putin
  • US / Chinese tycoon and Bannon ally Guo Wengui charged with $1bn fraud
  • Samsung to invest $230 billion to build mega chip cluster
  • Pentagon calls Moscow over drone incident
  • Credit Suisse slump renews fears of global banking crisis
  • Silicon Valley Bank execs, parent company sued after collapse
  • Credit Suisse Shares Plunge as Bank Storm Spreads to Europe
  • Dow tumbles nearly 500 points as Credit Suisse stokes fears of bank failure contagion
  • Russian jet, US drone crash over Black Sea, US military says
  • Dark hours for Credit Suisse Bank
  • Account full of holes at Credit Suisse
  • Russia blasts Canada over ‘regime change’
  • US / Sterling Bancorp, Inc. to Plead Guilty to $69M Securities Fraud
  • US drones have no business near Russia – ambassador
  • Inflation in Argentina surges past 100 percent in historic spike
  • Paris visitors alarmed at trash strike
  • China says AUKUS on ‘dangerous path’ with nuclear subs deal
  • Taiwan unveils portable attack drone as China tensions rise
  • Putin rejects theory about Ukrainian role in pipeline blasts
  • Syrian president Assad arrives in Moscow, set to meet Putin
  • Marin’s F-18 proposal fizzles, as a new Finnish NATO tack emerges
  • Ohio sues Norfolk Southern over toxic train derailment
  • US / ‘Forever chemicals’ in drinking water
  • Nord Stream blasts staged by a state-level actor – Putin
  • No Harvey Weinstein retrial on rape, sex assault charges
  • US / Silicon Valley Bank execs, parent company sued after collapse
  • As U.S. steps back from Middle East, China steps in
  • Western sanctions shielding Russian financial system from global crisis – Kremlin
  • Moody’s puts US banks on notice
  • Robert Kiyosaki predicts next big bank to fold
  • UK $6 billion defense boost targets atomic submarines, weapons top-up
  • BBC gets £20 million boost from UK govt
  • Document reveals why Canada arms Saudi Arabia – media
  • Taiwan braces for ‘total blockade’ – media
  • Biden administration lets Ukrainians who fled war stay in US
  • Ratings Deceit: S&P sued for deceitful CDO ratings
Rumble Video

Corruption Ledger Follow

The Public ▇▇▇ Ledger of ▇▇▇ Corruption. https://t.co/wkobrEotQR

5amResearch
Corruption Ledger @5amresearch ·
10 Feb

News Coverage of the September 2022 #NordStream Pipeline Attack https://corruptionledger.com/news-coverage-of-the-september-2022-nord-stream-pipeline-attack/ via @5amResearch

Reply on Twitter 1623868066818928641 Retweet on Twitter 1623868066818928641 Like on Twitter 1623868066818928641
Corruption Ledger @5amresearch ·
10 Feb

Mia Jankowicz of Business Insider calls Pulitzer prize-winning journalist Seymore Harsh a "discredited journalist." #NordStream

Reply on Twitter 1623857264086974464 Retweet on Twitter 1623857264086974464 Like on Twitter 1623857264086974464 1
Corruption Ledger @5amresearch ·
9 Feb

#Kraken to Discontinue Unregistered Offer and Sale of Crypto Asset Staking-As-A-Service Program and Pay $30 Million to Settle SEC Charges
https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2023-25

Reply on Twitter 1623815305452560384 Retweet on Twitter 1623815305452560384 Like on Twitter 1623815305452560384
Corruption Ledger @5amresearch ·
9 Feb

SpaceX: Ukraine breaching agreement, weaponizing Starlink https://en.mdn.tv/71FW

Reply on Twitter 1623685510496505860 Retweet on Twitter 1623685510496505860 Like on Twitter 1623685510496505860
Load More

–

  • Register
  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Copyright © 2022 Corruption Ledger. This web site contains no ads.