Skip to content

Corruption Ledger

The Public Ledger of Corruption

  • Corruption
    • banks
    • corporate
    • environment
    • government
    • health
    • leaks
    • misinformation
    • protest & unrest
  • Crime
  • Sanctions
    • sanctions news
    • global sanctions feed
    • european sanctions feed
    • canadian sanctions feed
    • US sanctions feed
  • International Conflict
    • war
    • war machines
  • Business & Economy
  • Tech
  • Privacy
  • Regions
    • Africas
    • Asias
    • Europe
    • Oceania
    • Middle East
    • U.S.
    • World
  • News about Journalism
  • Toggle search form
  • US / SEC sues Coinbase and Binance, files motion to freeze Binance assets _enforcement
  • Document reveals why Canada arms Saudi Arabia – media Business & Economy
  • Report: Russia formally charges Wall Street Journal reporter Censorship Free Speech
  • Kremlin comments on WSJ correspondent arrest Aerospace
  • Nord Stream attack: Leaked US intel. suggests pro-Ukrainian group behind sabotage + Corruption Ledger #RealityCheck corporate corruption
  • Kremlin critic Kara-Murza goes on trial for treason Censorship Free Speech
  • Wave of raids, arrests target government critics in Tunisia government corruption
  • Russia vs. journalism: Vladimir Putin must release Wall Street Journal reporter Evan Gershkovich Censorship Free Speech

Dominion’s Fox News defamation case headed to trial

Posted on April 1, 2023May 17, 2023 By 5amResearch No Comments on Dominion’s Fox News defamation case headed to trial

A jury will decide whether Fox Corp defamed Dominion Voting Systems with false vote-rigging claims aired by Fox News after the 2020 US election, a judge has ruled.

In a setback to the media company that had sought to avoid a trial in the $US1.6 billion ($A2.4 billion) lawsuit, Delaware Superior Court Judge Eric Davis on Friday denied motions from Fox and partially granted Dominion motions to resolve the issue of defamation liability ahead of the scheduled April 17 trial date.

The ruling puts the high-profile case in the hands of a jury that will determine whether Fox acted with actual malice and whether Dominion suffered any damages. The trial, to be held in Wilmington, is expected to last roughly four weeks. It is possible the parties could still settle the case. Davis heard arguments from both sides during a two-day pretrial hearing on March 21 and 22.

“This case is and always has been about the First Amendment protections of the media’s absolute right to cover the news,” Fox said in a statement. “Fox will continue to fiercely advocate for the rights of free speech and a free press as we move into the next phase of these proceedings.”

Dominion said it was gratified by the ruling and looked forward to the trial.

The suit is one of the most closely watched US defamation lawsuits in years and involves one of America’s largest cable networks, home to many prominent conservative commentators.

Denver-based Dominion sued New York-based Fox Corp and Fox News in 2021, accusing them of ruining its reputation by airing false claims by former President Donald Trump and his lawyers that its voting machines were used to rig the outcome of the election against him and in favour of Democrat Joe Biden.

Dominion has said in court filings that internal emails, texts and deposition testimony demonstrate Fox personnel at every level – from producers to hosts, all the way up to chairman Rupert Murdoch – knew the election-rigging claims were false and aired them anyway in pursuit of ratings as they lost viewers to far-right outlets that embraced Trump’s claims.

Dominion argued this met the “actual malice” standard to win a defamation case under which a plaintiff must prove a defendant knowingly spread false information or acted with reckless disregard for the truth.

Davis, however, said actual malice will be determined by the jury.

The judge ruled in Dominion’s favour on some elements of defamation including that the allegedly defamatory statements by Fox concerned Dominion, that the statements had been published by Fox and were false.

“The evidence developed in this civil proceeding demonstrates that (it) is CRYSTAL clear that none of the statements relating to Dominion about the 2020 election are true,” wrote Davis, using all capital letters for emphasis.

Fox has argued its coverage of the election claims was protected by press freedoms enshrined in the US Constitution’s First Amendment because it was newsworthy and properly framed as opinion or unproven allegations.

Fox has also argued Dominion’s suit advances an overly broad interpretation of US defamation law and is a threat to freedom of the press.

Lawyers for Fox also have invoked the legal doctrine of “neutral reportage,” which holds that the press cannot be held liable for publishing newsworthy allegations in a neutral way.

Davis, however, said in his ruling the doctrine would not shield Fox from liability because the network did not conduct disinterested reporting.

Fox faces a similar lawsuit by voting technology company Smartmatic, which is seeking $US2.7 billion ($A4.0 billion) in damages from Fox Corp, the cable network, Fox hosts and guests.

Australian Associated Press

Related

corporate corruption, Corruption, government corruption, Investigations, Spotlight Tags:All Regions, Corruption, Region Americas, Region US

Post navigation

Previous Post: REDWIRE investigation initiated by Former Louisiana Attorney General: Kahn Swick & Foti, LLC Investigates the Officers and Directors of Redwire Corporation
Next Post: IMF approves $15.6 billion Ukraine loan, part of $115 billion in global support

You must log in to post a comment.

Wall of Shame

  • Ledger of Lies
  • Enforcement Actions
  • Misinformation & Censorship
  • In Court

Recent

  • US / SEC sues Coinbase and Binance, files motion to freeze Binance assets
  • Raging Canada Wildfires Threaten Critical Infrastructure, Force Evacuations
  • Disgruntled employer Fox News says Tucker Carlson breached his contract: Report
  • Saudi crown prince, US’ Blinken had ‘candid’ talks in Jeddah
  • Italian police search former defense exec’s home in corruption probe
  • Meta to let users refuse its cross-site tracking following German antitrust intervention
  • Ex-CIA advisor theorizes date when Dollar’s dominance may start to crumble
  • Treasury ‘sleeping at the wheel’ on PwC tax scandal
  • Biden Signs Bill to Raise US Debt Ceiling to Avoid Default
  • A federal judge rejects Tennessee’s anti-drag law as too broad and vague
About CL
  • Russia moves ahead with deployment of tactical nuclear weapons in Belarus Defense and National Security
  • Fox Hit With Court Sanctions For Withholding Information In Dominion Libel Lawsuit corporate corruption
  • US DOJ opens Pentagon leaks investigation Defense and National Security
  • China says AUKUS on ‘dangerous path’ with nuclear subs deal International Conflict
  • Secretary Blinken’s Call with Russian Foreign Minister Lavrov Defense and National Security
  • Russian tech giants appeal Nasdaq delisting Business & Economy
Rumble Video

Copyright © 2022 Corruption Ledger. This web site contains no ads.