Skip to content

Corruption Ledger

The Public Ledger of Corruption

  • About
  • Corruption
    • corporate
    • government
    • leaks
    • misinformation
    • privacy and surveillance
    • protest and unrest
  • War
  • Sanctions
    • Sanctions News
    • Global Sanctions Feed
    • European Sanctions Feed
    • Canadian Sanctions Feed
    • US Sanctions Feed
  • Regions
    • Asias
    • Europe
    • Oceania
    • Middle East
    • US & Canada
    • World
  • Enforcement Actions
  • Economy
    • Crypto
  • Video
  • Freedom of Speech / Press
  • Toggle search form
  • Russia says jet scrambled as US B-52 bombers fly over Baltic Sea international conflict
  • Railroad reluctant to say who OK’d chemical burn after Ohio derailment corporate corruption
  • Scientists insist on continuing search for toxics in East Palestine corporate corruption
  • US announces sanctions on Iran drone procurement network _enforcement
  • Putin and Xi sign two documents in Moscow economy
  • JP Morgan, Deutsche Bank to face lawsuit over Epstein ties banks
  • Zuckerberg, Meta sued for failing to address sex trafficking, child exploitation corporate corruption
  • Top aide of Canadian PM Trudeau will testify in parliament on Chinese election meddling corporate corruption

Canada’s Supreme Court gives mixed rulings on gun crime penalties

Posted on January 27, 2023February 20, 2023 By CorruptionLedger No Comments on Canada’s Supreme Court gives mixed rulings on gun crime penalties
Canada’s Supreme Court found one mandatory minimum sentence for a firearm offense unconstitutional and upheld two others in a pair of decisions published on Friday.

Two of the three cases at issue used hypothetical scenarios that defense counsel argued could render these mandatory minimums unconstitutional because they would constitute cruel and unusual punishment in certain instances.

Mandatory minimum sentences have come under fire in Canada from advocates and lawyers who say they take discretion from judges and disproportionately penalize Indigenous and Black people who are over-represented behind bars and in Canada’s criminal justice system.

Canada has tighter gun laws than the United States but higher rates of gun ownership than some other rich countries. The federal government has been criticized by some gun rights advocates for tightening gun laws, including through a freeze on handgun purchases.

In one case, Jesse Dallas Hills had pleaded guilty to four charges, including recklessly discharging a firearm at a home in 2014 in Lethbridge, Alberta. That charge carried a mandatory minimum sentence of four years.

His counsel argued that in some cases, this mandatory minimum could constitute cruel and unusual punishment. The trial judge agreed; the appeal court did not.

The Hills ruling found this mandatory minimum unconstitutional and also said courts “should consider the effect of a sentence on the particular offender.” This is significant, said lawyer Chris Rudnicki, because it will oblige judges to consider whether Black or Indigenous offenders will have a harder time behind bars and perhaps change sentencings with that in mind.

In another case, Ocean Hilbach pleaded guilty to robbery with a prohibited firearm in Edmonton, Alberta, in 2017. The trial judge declared the five-year mandatory minimum penalty unconstitutional and an appeals court upheld that finding.

The Supreme Court found that penalty constitutional, as well as that imposed on Curtis Zwozdesky, who pleaded guilty to robbery with a firearm. His counsel used a hypothetical scenario to argue the four-year mandatory minimum sentence constituted cruel and unusual punishment.

Canada’s government repealed more than a dozen mandatory minimum sentences last year and some have been struck down by provincial courts but about 53 criminal offenses remain subject to mandatory minimum penalties, according to the justice department.

“Since 2016, the Department of Justice is aware of a total of 174 lower and appellate courts decisions that have found (mandatory minimum penalties) unconstitutional,” a spokesperson wrote in an email.

Thomson Reuters

https://japantoday.com/category/world/canada%27s-supreme-court-gives-mixed-rulings-on-gun-crime-penalties

Region US & Canada, Regions

Post navigation

Previous Post: China, U.S. spar at WTO meeting over disputes
Next Post: Usain Bolt fires business manager over Jamaica fraud case

See also

  • North Korea calls U.S. pledge of tanks to Ukraine ‘unethical crime’ corporate corruption
  • Sanctions Updates: Russia corruption
  • Justice Department Alleges Public Health Endangerment Caused by Denka Performance Elastomer’s Carcinogenic Air Pollution corporate corruption
  • Clearview AI settlement: Will stop selling facial recognition tool to private firms and continue working with law enforcement corporate corruption
  • Canada: Justin Trudeau’s healthcare funding decision considered low and is conditional, but on what? government corruption
  • Peru closes Machu Picchu as protesters face arrest in Lima corporate corruption

You must log in to post a comment.

  • Railroad reluctant to say who OK’d chemical burn after Ohio derailment
  • Scientists insist on continuing search for toxics in East Palestine
  • Top aide of Canadian PM Trudeau will testify in parliament on Chinese election meddling
  • Zuckerberg, Meta sued for failing to address sex trafficking, child exploitation
  • Norfolk Southern: Independent group finds toxic chemicals that Ohio EPA didn’t – Ohio train derailment (East Palestine)
  • JP Morgan, Deutsche Bank to face lawsuit over Epstein ties
  • Putin announces readiness to switch to the Chinese Yuan currency in foreign trade
  • Putin and Xi sign two documents in Moscow
  • US announces sanctions on Iran drone procurement network
  • Russia says jet scrambled as US B-52 bombers fly over Baltic Sea
Rumble Video

Corruption Ledger Follow

The Public ▇▇▇ Ledger of ▇▇▇ Corruption. https://t.co/wkobrEotQR

5amResearch
Corruption Ledger @5amresearch ·
10 Feb

News Coverage of the September 2022 #NordStream Pipeline Attack https://corruptionledger.com/news-coverage-of-the-september-2022-nord-stream-pipeline-attack/ via @5amResearch

Reply on Twitter 1623868066818928641 Retweet on Twitter 1623868066818928641 Like on Twitter 1623868066818928641
Corruption Ledger @5amresearch ·
10 Feb

Mia Jankowicz of Business Insider calls Pulitzer prize-winning journalist Seymore Harsh a "discredited journalist." #NordStream

Reply on Twitter 1623857264086974464 Retweet on Twitter 1623857264086974464 Like on Twitter 1623857264086974464 1
Corruption Ledger @5amresearch ·
9 Feb

#Kraken to Discontinue Unregistered Offer and Sale of Crypto Asset Staking-As-A-Service Program and Pay $30 Million to Settle SEC Charges
https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2023-25

Reply on Twitter 1623815305452560384 Retweet on Twitter 1623815305452560384 Like on Twitter 1623815305452560384
Corruption Ledger @5amresearch ·
9 Feb

SpaceX: Ukraine breaching agreement, weaponizing Starlink https://en.mdn.tv/71FW

Reply on Twitter 1623685510496505860 Retweet on Twitter 1623685510496505860 Like on Twitter 1623685510496505860
Load More

–

  • Register
  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Copyright © 2022 Corruption Ledger. This web site contains no ads.